If you have ever felt a little flicker of self-consciousness when someone asks what kind of dog you have, you are not imagining it. Doodle parents get side-eye from the purebred world and from the rescue world at the same time. This week, New Yorker staff writer John Seabrook joins me to unpack why, and what months of reporting taught him about the dogs we love.
Prefer to listen? Catch this episode on your favorite podcast player, or hit play right here.
Doodles Get Judged From Both Sides
John said something in our conversation that I have felt for years but never heard put so cleanly. Doodles take it from both directions. The purebred community can view them as impure, and the rescue community can view them as the dog you paid for instead of saved. It is a strange spot to stand in, and most Doodle parents feel it without ever naming it.
John saw this firsthand at Meet the Breeds at the Javits Center in New York. He is a genuine dog lover, so he fell into easy conversations with breeders, until the moment he mentioned he had a Goldendoodle. He calls it the vibe shift. The poodle people, he found, tend to be the most skeptical of Doodles, often asking the same pointed question: why not just get a poodle?
I know that question well. I lived it. So instead of trading sides, John and I did something the dog world rarely does. We sat in the middle, with curiosity instead of defensiveness, and looked at what is actually true.
Are Doodles Healthier Than Purebreds? What the Science Actually Says
This is the part every Doodle parent wants a straight answer on, so here it is. There is no guarantee with any dog. A purebred is not automatically healthy, and a Doodle is not automatically health tested. What matters is the breeder’s choices, not the label on the puppy.
John had his Goldendoodle, Herman, DNA tested and looked at his coefficient of inbreeding, or COI. This is the number that estimates how genetically related a dog’s parents are. Herman came back at under one percent. A typical purebred Golden Retriever or Poodle often sits around twenty percent. That gap is the whole conversation in a single statistic.
This is where hybrid vigor comes in, the idea that crossing two relatively distinct genetic lines can lower the odds of inherited disease. John is careful and honest here, and so am I. The data is not absolute, and hybrid vigor is debated in the breeding world. But a thoughtfully bred first-generation or multi-generation Doodle from health-tested parents is, in his words, giving yourself a better shot.
What protects that better shot is testing. Organizations like the Goldendoodle Association of North America hold breeders to a more rigorous health-testing standard than the basic registry requirement, including genetic testing and a pledge not to breed dogs more closely related than third cousins. That third-cousin rule exists to avoid exactly the kind of inherited heartbreak that pushed one breeder John met, a former champion Great Dane breeder named Cindy, to walk away from the show world entirely after her dogs kept dying young.
The Surprising History: “Breed” Is a Victorian Invention
Here is the fact that reframes the entire purebred-versus-Doodle debate. We tend to imagine breeds as ancient, going back to Roman mastiffs or medieval hunting dogs. They are not. As John explains, the modern idea of a closed, pedigreed breed was largely invented in the mid-nineteenth century. Before that, dogs were loose, overlapping varieties, not fixed breeds with studbooks.
That history matters because it takes the pressure off the word pure. Most retrievers are not retrieving anymore. Most ratting terriers are not ratting. Many breeds were created for jobs that no longer exist, then sold on the romance of those jobs. Doodles, by contrast, were honest from the start about what they are for. They are companions. That is the job.
John also pointed to a cultural divide that explains so much of the friction. The purebred world grew up on a nineteenth-century amateur ideal, betterment of the breed, not marketing, word of mouth rather than websites. The Doodle world grew up alongside social media as an openly consumer-led, commercial enterprise. Neither origin makes a dog more or less worthy. They are just different cultures, and the tension between them is really a culture clash, not a referendum on the dogs.
Why Doodles Are So Pro-Social (and Why They Jump)
One of my favorite moments came when John and I talked about why Doodles greet the world the way they do. Doodles are intensely pro-social. They want to be face-to-face with you, because face-to-face is how dogs greet. That same wiring is why they so often jump.
I shared what my training mentor, Jean Donaldson, the founder of the Academy for Dog Trainers, once said to me. She specializes in Chows, and she pointed out that Chow owners would give anything for a drop of the pro-social instinct Doodle parents are busy trying to manage. So many breeds require enormous effort just to feel relaxed around a new person. Doodles arrive overflowing with the desire to connect. That is a gift, even on the days it lands as muddy paws on your guest.
This is exactly why I teach polite greetings rather than suppression. We are not trying to shut down a pro-social dog. We are channeling that beautiful instinct into something calmer and more livable, using science-based positive reinforcement.
The Wally Conron “Regret” Myth, and How to Find an Ethical Breeder
If you have spent any time in Doodle comment sections, you have seen the Wally Conron quote, the man credited with naming the Labradoodle, later saying it was the regret of his life and that he had created a monster. John tracked this story carefully. Conron did not invent crossing a Poodle with a Lab. What he really did was give it a name, and that name helped the dogs find homes. John believes that single bad-day quote has been wildly overweighted by critics, and frankly, so do I.
What deserves far more attention is how you actually bring a Doodle home. The pandemic boom created puppy mills and online puppy brokers who ship a dog to you sight unseen, so you never meet the parents or see where the puppy was raised. John would not have gotten a Doodle that way, and neither should you. His own dog came from a hobby breeder twenty minutes away, a registered nurse whose own retriever and poodle were the parents. The opposite of a puppy mill.
This is the heart of why I do what I do. My own Standard Poodle passed at just four years old from a congenital issue, before I understood how much breeder selection matters. That heartbreak is the reason I curate a vetted network of ethical Doodle breeders, so families can skip the grief I went through and start with a healthy, well-bred puppy.
Key Takeaways
The biggest shift from this conversation is permission to stop defending your dog and start understanding the landscape. Doodles get judged from both sides because they sit at the intersection of two very different dog cultures, one built on a Victorian idea of purity and one built openly for companionship. Neither origin tells you whether an individual dog is healthy or loved.
Health is not about the purebred-versus-Doodle label. It is about testing, genetic diversity, and an honest breeder. A low coefficient of inbreeding and a breeder who follows standards like genetic testing and the third-cousin rule matter far more than the word on the paperwork. And the pro-social wiring that makes Doodles jump is the same wiring that makes them extraordinary companions, which is something to shape with kindness, not crush.
Most of all, how you source your puppy is one of the most loving decisions you will ever make. Meet the parents. See the home. Choose a breeder who tests. It protects your dog, your heart, and your wallet for the next decade and beyond.
There is no guarantee with any dog, but a well-bred Doodle can have a health advantage. Crossing two distinct genetic lines can produce hybrid vigor and a lower coefficient of inbreeding, or COI. A typical purebred often sits near 20 percent COI, while a thoughtfully bred Doodle can be far lower. What matters most is a breeder who does genetic and health testing, not the purebred or Doodle label itself.
A coefficient of inbreeding, or COI, is a percentage that estimates how genetically related a dog’s parents are. A lower number means more genetic diversity and generally lower odds of inherited disease. Many purebred dogs carry a COI around 20 percent, while a first-generation or carefully bred multi-generation Doodle can come in dramatically lower. You can find your dog’s COI through DNA testing.
Doodles sit between two very different dog cultures. The purebred world can view them as impure, and parts of the rescue world can view them as the dog you bought instead of saved. Much of this is a culture clash rooted in a Victorian idea of breed purity, not a real measure of whether an individual dog is healthy, well-bred, or loved.
Wally Conron, credited with naming the Labradoodle, gave one widely shared interview calling it a regret, and critics quote it constantly. Reporting suggests this single comment has been heavily overweighted. Conron did not invent crossing a Poodle and a Lab, he named it, and that name helped the dogs find homes. Many see his real legacy as the joy these companion dogs have brought to families.
Choose a breeder who health tests and follows recognized standards, such as rigorous health testing (beyond genetic testing) and avoiding breeding dogs more closely related than third cousins. Ask to meet the puppy’s parents and see where the puppy is raised. Avoid online puppy brokers who ship sight unseen, since you never verify the home or the parents. The Doodle Pro’s Gold Standard Circle are vetted breeders who you can trust. Search the directory at https://thedoodlepro.com/gold-standard-circle-doodle-breeders/
Doodles jump because they are intensely pro-social and want to greet you face-to-face, which is how dogs naturally greet each other. It is connection, not bad behavior. The goal is not to suppress that wonderful instinct but to channel it into a calmer, polite greeting using science-based positive reinforcement. The Doodle Pro’s course Zoomies to Zen teaches you just that.
Meet Jean Donaldson and More at The Doodle Pro® Summit
If this conversation lit something up in you, here is your next step. Jean Donaldson, the mentor I mention in this episode, is one of the speakers at The Doodle Pro® Summit: Doodle Parent Edition 2026, happening July 27 to 29. The whole event is built on one promise: raise the whole Doodle, not just train one. No shame, no blame, just science-based guidance from the people I trust most in this industry.
And if this episode has you thinking about where your next Doodle should come from, this is exactly why I built my vetted breeder network. After losing my own Standard Poodle far too young, I curated a circle of ethical, health-testing Doodle breeders so families can start with confidence instead of crossed fingers.
Find an Ethical Doodle Breeder
Related Episodes You’ll Love
- Goldendoodles 101 (the perfect companion to this breed-history conversation)
- Are Doodles a Breed? What the Critics Get Wrong
- What the 2026 Doodle Behavior Study Actually Found
Full Episode Transcript
Click to read the full episode transcript
John: Doodles get it from both sides, really. The purebred people resent them because they’re sort of impure breeds in some way, and then the rescue people resent them because you pay for them usually.
Corinne: John, I’ve been looking forward to our chat today ever since I read your article in The New Yorker, which was truly a deep dive into Doodles and the business of Doodles and the politics of Doodles.
John: Yeah, Corinne, I’m really happy to talk to you. I love talking Doodles, so thanks for having me on the show.
Corinne: No surprise, I do too, but something might surprise you. We were in the same room in January. We were both at the Goldendoodle Association of North America conference. I was chit-chatting with some of the breeders, so you and I were like the two exceptions of people in the room that aren’t Doodle breeders.
John: Right. Yeah. I had a nice time. The first day, and you kind of talked about this in your article, was a bit more about the business of breeding. As a business owner, I’m more familiar with creating websites and branding, and the people in that room are more about building dogs and literally breeding. Day two as a non-breeder was really getting down into artificial insemination, tube feeding, OFA X-rays and all that. That was a little beyond what I needed for my article.
Corinne: What I thought was interesting was the contrast between you going to Westminster, feeling like a bit of a pariah, to what you call DoodleCon.
John: I went to Meet the Breeds, which is in the Javits Center. AKC, I think there are like 150 of the 205 recognized breeds. Each breed has its own pavilion with information and a breeder behind the desk. I’d engage breeders in conversation. Clearly I was a dog lover, very enthusiastic. Then inevitably the question would arise, what kind of dog do you have? And I would tell them I had a Goldendoodle. And at that moment the vibe shift occurred. Pretty major vibe shift. The poodle people are the ones that are most anti-Doodle, quite reasonably I suppose.
John: I got into a nice conversation with someone named Joyce, whose show dog was right on the table in front of us. I was going to give her my card, and I always have a roll of poop bags in my pocket, and the whole thing unspooled right in front of her. I was waiting for the question, what kind of dog do you have? I’d decided I would just say I have a mutt. But she didn’t ask, and I hurried away. Later she read the article. I sent it to her and said, you never asked, but in fact I have a Goldendoodle. She sent back a very nice email saying she loved it.
John: I used a word in the article, a Filipino English word, gigil, which the Oxford English Dictionary made an official word last year. It means something so unbearably cute that you almost want to pinch it. That was my experience when I saw Herman as a puppy for the very first time. The poodle person said she felt gigil while reading the article.
Corinne: I love that. It was so thoroughly researched and balanced. You’ve had other breeds before Herman, right?
John: I grew up on a farm, a rural dog experience, which means there were often puppies nearby. I had a mix of mongrels and purebreds. My dad had a Standard Poodle when I was born, and I think that dog is in the back of my mind, because when Herman has a poodle cut he looks like that dog. I had retrievers, which I loved, but hip dysplasia was a thing, and cancer was the way that dog died. When I moved to the city I had cats. Then when I got married and we had kids, we got a rescue from an organization in Scarsdale that brings dogs up from the South. A fantastic dog, we had her for 16 years.
John: When she died there was a mourning period. My brother has a Goldendoodle and was always talking about how great theirs was. We have a place in Vermont, a farm. There was an ad in the small-town paper for a litter of Goldendoodles. It reminded me of how we got dogs in my youth. We saw the litter, took my kids, and it was over. We got Herman at nine weeks. Now he goes back and forth between Brooklyn and Vermont, off leash in the country, on leash in the city with a hundred dogs in the park. He’s adapted incredibly well. Really well socialized. Never fights. If a dog is aggressive, he just lies down. He’s never really had a day of trauma in his life. With a rescue there’s a period you don’t know about. With Herman, I know every single day he’s been well loved.
Corinne: You talk in the article about the dog parks in New York and the virtue signaling about how hard a life your rescue had.
John: There’s a lot of it. The harder it was, the higher the status. A retired greyhound, a pit bull rescued from a violent situation. Those people are incredible, they have the love and care to endure whatever they have to. In the status hierarchy they’re at the top, and I’m happy to give them that place. Doodles are definitely not a dog to get if you’re looking for status in New York City dog parks. So Doodles get it from both sides. The purebred people resent them because they’re impure, and the rescue people resent them because you paid for them. Although there are now a lot of Doodles in shelters too. A lot of people got Doodles during the pandemic, found out how expensive and time-consuming they are, and they ended up rehomed.
Corinne: You and I share that we both have had Standard Poodles, and that’s said a lot from the poodle organizations, why don’t you just get a poodle? I have on my desk a little ceramic of my late Standard Poodle in a show cut. She died at four. Of a congenital issue. Now I know more about how I could have selected a breeder, knowing more about health testing. Just that it’s a purebred isn’t a guarantee, and just because it’s a Doodle isn’t a guarantee they’re not health tested.
John: I’m actually surprised a Standard Poodle from a breeder wasn’t health tested.
Corinne: I was younger. Lesson learned. You talked to a couple of breeders at GANA who are in my special curated network of Doodle breeders, to try to save people from the heartbreak I went through. Amy Lane with Fox Creek Farm is one of them. She started Mini Goldendoodles in 2002, and talks about genetic diversity, the third-cousin rule, not breeding father to daughter.
John: If you want to belong to GANA you have to agree to a much more rigorous regime of health testing than the AKC requires, including genetic testing. And you have to pledge you won’t breed your dog to any dog closer than a third cousin, to avoid inherited congenital diseases. One powerful experience at GANA was meeting a breeder named Cindy, a South Carolina breeder who used to breed Great Danes. She had grand champion Great Danes, but they were plagued with spine problems, and her last champion died young. She was so upset she said I can’t do this anymore. She heard about GANA’s health requirements and converted to the Goldendoodle world. Her AKC friends treated her like the Antichrist. She lost friends, but she’s much happier and hasn’t had those issues.
John: With a first-generation Goldendoodle the parents are purebred, so they might carry inherited diseases. But you get hybrid vigor from crossing two relatively distinct genetic lines. Hybrid vigor is controversial, the data isn’t definite. But I did a DNA test of Herman and his coefficient of inbreeding, the COI, was less than one percent, whereas a typical Golden Retriever or purebred Poodle is around twenty percent. That suggests your chances are better of a healthy dog, at least with a first-generation cross. But it’s no guarantee. You’re just giving yourself a better shot.
Corinne: People think they’re getting a Golden without the shedding and a little healthier, ignoring the poodle traits that come with it, and it’s not a guarantee which traits you’re pulling, which is why genetic testing is wonderful. Hearing Cindy’s heartbreak twofold, watching her champions pass early and grieving the friends she lost. There were other breeders at the conference, one of Dalmatians, one of toy poodles, who said please don’t mention my name because I’m AKC and not supposed to associate with the Doodle world. But this is an educational conference.
John: I have Dalmatians too. Both of ours had hearing issues linked to breed standards, breeding for more white and isolated spots was linked to deafness. If you have children around a deaf dog it can be hazardous, the dog doesn’t hear the child coming.
Corinne: In your article you dive into the Victorian parallels. These breed standards and accepted breeds haven’t been around permanently.
John: A lot of people think breeds are ancient strains going back to the Middle Ages or Roman times. In fact the whole idea of breed was basically invented in the mid-19th century. Before that they were overlapping varieties. People didn’t take pedigree seriously until the Victorian era, with foundational dogs. The show world has gotten criticism for these practices and reacted by closing itself off, only caring what each other think. It’s a closed-off subculture competing not really for money. In the purebred world you don’t talk about money or marketing. You go by word of mouth. That’s part of a 19th-century amateur ideal of betterment of the breed.
John: That’s a cultural difference. The Doodle world basically started as a commercial endeavor. It was a guide dog originally, bred for people allergic to retrievers and labs. But early on, particularly in the States, it came from Australia and was commercial from the get-go, with advertising and websites. The Doodle phenomenon parallels the rise of social media. They grew up together. Purebred breeders were established long before social media and never embraced it. At DoodleCon there was a whole day on marketing and website optimization, which I found refreshing, but to a classic purebred person that might seem grossly commercial.
Corinne: The derogatory term used to label this is breeders, in quotes. If you’re not deemed an official breed you can’t get titles, you can’t participate, so people have to find you other ways. This industry came in a different way, consumer-led, instead of based on the virtue of a gun dog hunting geese.
John: Poodles arose at a time when the functions the original breeds were created for no longer existed. Most retrievers weren’t retrieving birds. Yet they were still presented as for that purpose. When Doodles came along, it was like, this dog is just for your family, it’s a companion, and it doesn’t shed. There was an honesty to it. And the idea of a companion dog, a therapy dog. These dogs are very emotionally available. If you’re having a bad day and want to give your dog a long hug, our dog seems to really invite that. I had a great conversation with an ex-soldier from Iraq who got into dog breeding and supplies Doodles to his buddies with PTSD.
Corinne: Australian Labradoodles in particular are bred for that purpose. When you have a skilled breeder, temperament is one of the top features. They lean into you. I was speaking with my training mentor, Jean Donaldson, the founder of positive reinforcement training, who specializes in Chows. People complain that Doodles jump on people, and she said they’re so pro-social that they want to be face-to-face. That’s how dogs communicate.
John: I agree with that. They want to stand up like people sometimes too.
Corinne: She said, do you know what Chow owners would give to have a drop of that pro-social instinct? There are breeds you have to work so hard for just to feel relaxed when a new person is around. And Doodle parents, we’re struggling with you’re too excited for the guest to come over.
John: I don’t want Herman jumping on people. But when you meet somebody who gets it, they know the dog isn’t misbehaving, the dog is greeting you with a full-body hug. If you submit to it, it’s a great feeling. He’s a standard Goldendoodle, his eye level isn’t much below mine, and we have a wonderful moment together on the street corner.
Corinne: When we talk about purpose, you mentioned the so-called founder Wally Conron. He was breeding labs for therapy dogs, someone was allergic, so he crossed them with a poodle and the Labradoodle was born. It’s often quoted by critics that in later interviews he said it was the greatest regret of his life, that he felt he had built Frankenstein.
John: Everyone who has a beef about Doodles quotes that. On Reddit it comes up every other comment. I wonder whether Wally was just having a bad day. I tried to reach him to see if he wanted to recant. If this is your life’s regret, you’ve had a darn good life, because you provided a lot of joy. I never could find him. If he’s alive he’s 97. He didn’t intend that to be his legacy. His legacy is he did a wonderful thing. And he wasn’t the first to cross a Poodle and a Lab. What he really did was name it. Nobody wanted the two siblings of the dog that went to the blind, allergic person. They didn’t want the mutts. Then he said, let’s call them a Labradoodle, and everybody wanted them. It was the word that drove the marketing.
Corinne: If anyone was going to get a final comment, it would be a staff writer at The New Yorker. He was a leader in dog training and breeding, and that community likes to preserve the breed, so this invention of the Doodle would be frowned upon. When they became hot and consumer-led, there were breeders who didn’t health test, and puppy farms. Luckily that demand has dropped and thinned out a lot.
John: You’re absolutely right, Doodles are such a commodity, especially in the pandemic. Not so much the puppy mills themselves now, but the puppy brokers who create the websites. You never really know where the dog came from, they say they’ll bring it to you, you never see the facility or meet the parents. I would never have gotten a Doodle that way. In our case there was a person 20 minutes away, and the poodle and the retriever were her own dogs. She was a hobby breeder, a registered nurse. The opposite of a puppy mill. I had a good feeling about her, a lot of kindness and love. I’d encourage everyone, if you can, go visit the breeder and see where they’re living. These websites make it instant gratification, like Amazon, this puppy’s available today, and that often leads to getting your dog from the wrong place.
Corinne: Yours sounds almost romantic, that it was an actual physical newspaper listing.
John: The fact that it was a classified ad in a newspaper, which basically doesn’t exist anymore, was a big part of it. As a journalist I’ve watched the ad business model disappear with the rise of Facebook. The New Yorker is a unique case because subscribers are so loyal, it’s driven by subscriptions, not ads. So supporting the local paper and showing classified ads still serve a purpose was important to me.
Corinne: You mentioned one of the breeders gave you a Live Laugh Bark Doodle calendar, and you thought maybe you’re ready for the double-Doodle life.
John: That was Cindy. We do now talk constantly about getting another dog, because Herman is always happy with other dogs, and it would take pressure off us. But we’d probably not get a Doodle. My wife felt the karma imbalance of two Doodles versus a Doodle and a rescue. A Doodle and a rescue would balance it out. The only thing is, my children came with us to meet the dog and were going to help look after it, and that went out the window quickly. The eternal promise. My son’s 27, my daughter’s 17 and going to college next year.
Corinne: I’m going to steal your term, gigil. Am I saying it right?
John: Yes. The emotion of gigil is provoked by these incredibly cute puppies, and the Doodle with the teddy bear features is off the charts cute.
Corinne: Did I miss anything, or anything you’d like to cover?
John: I reached out to the AKC on a number of occasions. You think of The New Yorker and dogs, the cartoons, the long history, mostly purebred dogs. The audience is probably a fairly purebred-loving type. So when I reached out saying I’m doing a long article about Goldendoodles but I’m looking to get both sides, you’d think the AKC would at least talk to me. But they’re so defensive that they wouldn’t even speak to me, not even off the record. Just, we don’t talk about Doodles, period. This is an organization that’s gone from a certain number of registrations in the early ’90s to a decline of two-thirds today. It’s really an organization in crisis, and part of the reason is they’ve gotten themselves into a box. No Doodles are breeds. Maybe one day they will be. Think of all the registrations they’d gain. You’re not going to register the first generations because the genetics are unpredictable, but we’re in a world now where multi-gen Doodles are very common. Amy Lane only sells multi-gen Doodles, and these lines breed true. So they have the qualities of breeds. The Australian Labradoodles have made an effort to be registered. The AKC needs to reorient and get out of this defensive crouch.
Corinne: That’s fascinating, and part of why I exist is that in the training world people don’t really talk about Doodles, or do so with disdain. I have a highly accredited dog training friend who confided, I’m so glad you exist to work with Doodles so I don’t have to. That’s a common refrain. We talk about the enthusiasm and exercise needs, and some people think they’re plug and play, but their needs are higher than expected. But to just not entertain the conversation from AKC, that’s really interesting.
John: It seems like they’re shooting themselves in the foot.
Corinne: Well, thank you for that insight. Is there anything else?
John: No, I think that’s it. I think we got it.
Corinne: Wonderful. Thank you. I really enjoyed this article, and I’m glad Herman comes home. This has been such a pleasure.
John: Thanks for having me on the show. I really liked it.
What's Your Doodle's Job Title? 🐾
Six quick questions reveal what your Doodle is really up to all day, plus how to help them love their job! 💼🐶