Puppy Culture 101: Raising Confident, Resilient Doodles with Jane Messineo Lindquist

Is life with your Doodle more chaotic than calm?
Whether your Doodle is still a puppy or you’re years into your life together, understanding early-life protocols like Puppy Culture, ENS, and Simulated Maternal Stimulation (SMS) can completely change your dog’s confidence and communication skills.

In this episode of The Doodle Pro® Podcast, I sit down with Jane Messineo Lindquist, founder of Puppy Culture and author of When Pigs Fly! Training Success with Impossible Dogs, to unpack what these protocols really mean — and how they help raise dogs who are optimistic, resilient, and able to politely ask for what they need.


Listen to the Episode

Puppy Culture 101 – Raising Confident, Resilient Doodles

Listen on Apple Podcasts | Listen on Spotify


Why Puppy Culture Matters for Doodles

Doodles are known for their intelligence, sensitivity, and boundless enthusiasm — but without the right foundation, those traits can quickly turn into leash pulling, excessive barking, and over-excitement.

Puppy Culture blends science-backed protocols with age-appropriate enrichment to:

  • Build confidence in new situations
  • Reduce behavior issues later in life
  • Create clear communication between dog and owner

Jane and I discuss why genetics are only part of the equation and how early-life experiences shape a dog’s temperament and adaptability.

Active vs. Passive Enrichment

Not all enrichment is created equal.

  • Active enrichment: Activities where your dog must physically or mentally engage (e.g., puzzle feeders, scent games, interactive play).
  • Passive enrichment: Environmental factors your dog can experience without direct participation (e.g., safe exposure to new smells, sounds, or surfaces).

Both are critical — and knowing when and how to use them can mean the difference between a bored, frustrated Doodle and one who’s happily settled at your feet.

When Pigs Fly! by Jane Messineo Lindquist

What Is “Manding” — and Why Should You Teach It?

Manding is a polite, learned behavior your dog offers to communicate a need — think “sit” or “stand calmly” instead of barking or pawing.

It’s not just “sit for petting.” Manding teaches dogs to:

  • Request attention without frustration
  • Learn that calm behavior works to get what they want
  • Develop communication skills that last beyond the puppy stage

Even if your Doodle is already an adult, you can still introduce manding to replace unwanted behaviors with polite ones.

Attention Is the Mother of All Behaviors – Puppy Culture

ENS vs. Simulated Maternal Stimulation (SMS)

Early Neurological Stimulation (ENS) has become a buzzword in the breeder and puppy training world — but is it really the gold standard?

Jane breaks down:

  • The original purpose of ENS
  • Why Simulated Maternal Stimulation (SMS) may be a better fit for some puppies
  • What current science says about both

If you’ve ever been confused by the debate or wondered what’s actually best for puppies, this segment is a must-listen.

How to Choose a Responsible Doodle Breeder

If you’re adding a Doodle puppy to your home, look for breeders who:

  • Follow age-appropriate enrichment protocols like Puppy Culture
  • Started crate comfort training
  • Reinforced recall skills
  • Teach manding before the puppy goes home
  • Provide safe, structured exposure to new environments and people
  • Track and share developmental milestones

These practices mean you’re not just “getting lucky” with a great puppy — you’re benefiting from intentional, proven preparation.

FAQ – Puppy Culture & Doodle Training

When should you start Puppy Culture?

The ideal window is from birth to 12 weeks, but the principles can benefit dogs at any age.

Is ENS necessary for every puppy?

Not necessarily — SMS and other tailored protocols can be more appropriate depending on the litter’s needs.

Can older dogs learn manding?

Yes! Even adult dogs can learn polite ways to communicate their needs using manding.

Do I need to buy the whole Puppy Culture program?

No. You can start with individual resources like When Pigs Fly! or Attention Is the Mother of All Behaviors and build from there.

Next Step: The Doodle Parent Challenge

The long-awaited Doodle Parent Challenge is back on September 5th — and this Motivation Edition will teach your Doodle to politely tell you what they want.

  • Cut out the barking and pawing
  • Build better communication
  • Make everyday life smoother and more fun

The Doodle Parent Challenge

Sign up for The Doodle Parent Challenge here

Don’t miss Part 2 of this conversation where we discuss safe socialization before vaccinations are complete, what to avoid, and Jane’s must-do advice for breeders and puppy parents. Subscribe to The Doodle Pro® Podcast here:

Puppy culture part 1

[00:00:00] Today’s episode is part one of my conversation with Jane Mess, Linquist, the brilliant mind behind puppy culture. In this first half, we’ll dive into the origins of the very popular puppy culture, what it really teaches, why early protocols matter so much, and a fresh look at things like Manding and ENS.

Next week in part two, we’ll cover safe socialization before all the vaccines, tips for adult and rescue dogs and the two breeder habits. Jane says, change everything. So be sure to follow the podcast so you don’t miss it.

Doodle breed. Dogs are easy to love, but can be challenging to parent. I’m Doodle expert Karin Gearhart, also known as the Doodle Pro, and I’m here to help doodle parents have a more fulfilling and rewarding experience with their doodles. No [00:01:00] one has professionally worked with as many different doodle breeds, or has more experience with doodles than I have, and I love to share my expertise in a fun, compassionate, and non-judgmental way.

From my years of work and education in the pet care and dog training industry, I have an incredible network of skilled training. Grooming and veterinary professionals to share their knowledge with you and give you the doodle specific answers you are looking for. I hope you enjoy today’s episode as I help you parent your doodle like a pro.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: Today’s guest is a true trailblazer in the world of dog training and puppy rearing. And while she’s best known for her work with Bull Terriers, her impact has rippled through every breed and mix, including our beloved doodles. Jane.

Menia. Linquist is the brilliant mind behind puppy culture, the groundbreaking film and program [00:02:00] that’s changed how. An entire generation of breeders and pet parents raise their puppies. She’s also the author of the cult favorite book, when Pigs Fly, training Success with Impossible Dogs, which offers hope and real results.

For those of us with strong-willed pups. Jane has been in the dog world for over 40 years. Breeding, showing judging and presenting seminars all over the globe. Her kennel, madcap Bull Terriers has produced over 100 confirmation and performance titles proving that even the most independent breeds can shine in both the show ring and performance arenas.

As an A KC judge, the Bull Terrier Club of America’s a KC Delegate and a passionate advocate for early socialization and enrichment. Jane’s work has united trainers, breeders, rescues, and pet parents around one shared goal giving [00:03:00] puppies their very best start. She has helped over 80,000 puppy culture fans around the world, and today she’s here to share her wisdom with the Doodle Pro community.

Let’s give a warm welcome to the Jane. Hello. How are you? Corinne,? What a lovely introduction. Thank you so much. I must say I brought home my doodle cpo Nestle. March of 2020 and he was supposed to come home at that time. Yeah. And I, even though I had worked with hundreds of doodles, and this is my profession, I still was at a loss of how do I socialize this pup?

When the world is shut down.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Yes. And

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: you offered. A program and it was complimentary just to help pop parents who were in the same situation just to help [00:04:00] them get through it. And it helped my dog and I so much just practicing Manding and the box game and you are just an incredible resource.

And I’m personally thrilled to introduce you to our audience for those who haven’t already gotten to hear about all of your great work.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: I’m so excited to be here. Thank you so much for having me.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: My pleasure. For listeners who are brand new to puppy culture can you share more about what it is and how you created it?

Sure.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: It was so many things an accident because I was a professional dog trainer and I’d written this book when Pigs Fly that you mentioned the way that I came to write when Pigs Fly is that. I have two. I always say I have two loves in this world. Two passions, bull terriers and dog agility, which are oxymorons, right?

It’s just about impossible to get a bull [00:05:00] terrier to do this. But somehow I was managing to do it. And people kept saying, you, how did you do this? I don’t understand. And I would explain it to them. And then finally someone said you should write a book. And I did. Okay. So this book takes off and as you say, it’s a cult.

Classic, and I was making a movie version of the book, but we happened to have a litter on the ground. Oh. And I said, you know what? Lemme make a 20 minute film just on the developmental periods in puppies. And that turned into just being an enormous four year project that wound up being in a five, five hour film puppy culture.

And I think what happened as I was making the film, I was connecting dots as a dog breeder, as a trainer, and as a performance sport enthusiast. And what I was [00:06:00] seeing is that. A lot of the things that people think of as behavior problems are really errors or omissions in the very early part of the puppy’s life.

So it’s a lack or an incomplete or an incorrect socialization or upbringing that people then perceive as a behavior problem or a personality trait in the dog. I realized that probably seriously, 80% of the problems that dog trainers face could be circumvented by the right early protocols, and that’s what puppy culture is about,

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: which is a remarkable gift that we can be breeding with intention, but then taking that next step is.

It’s just such a wonderful opportunity.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Absolutely. The thing is nothing trumps [00:07:00] genetics. As a breeder, you always have to be starting with the best genetics, and as a puppy owner, you should always be looking for the best genetics. What are the temperaments of the parents?

What are the temperaments, if you know of the five generation pedigree, but. Past that. As I say, it’s genetics draws a box of possibilities, and you want that box of possibilities to be as good as possible. But within that box where you land, it’s all up to you. And that’s again, what puppy culture is about.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: And when we describe puppy culture, I mean you mentioned that it, what do you say, it’s a four hour film. And then it’s developed so much more than that.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: So when

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: people hear puppy culture, is it just a philosophy or are there specific exercises that people are doing for someone completely unfamiliar? Can you share what does that expectation, that shared language mean?

Jane Messineo Lindquist: We have a whole [00:08:00] family of educational products. Under the same puppy culture umbrella. Now when pigs fly puppy culture, and now we also have Madcap University. Yeah. Puppy culture is concerned with raising behaviorally sound puppies. So it’s not a lot of husbandry, it’s not a lot of training per se, like performance training or.

That kind of thing. It’s more about raising puppies with emotional resilience. Handing over a blank slate to the puppy owner that they can then work with. So the protocols in puppy culture are all geared toward that behavioral side. Now it does start at birth. With things like ENS that maybe we’ll talk a little bit more about, but, and it does.

I’m gonna say it does also include enrichment, [00:09:00] but we divide enrichment into active and passive enrichment. So passive enrichment is things like toys, an enriched environment, that kind of thing, that it looks very. Sexy, for lack of a better way of saying it all. All the stuff, all the equipment, and it’s great.

It is important. It’s part of toys and those things. They’re all part of an enriched environment. But I would say where the rubber really meets the road as far as puppy culture is concerned, is what we call the active enrichment items. Which are training manding. Anti resource guarding protocols, crate and confinement conditioning, early toilet training.

Socialization. Those are the things that really are the hallmarks and the game changers with puppy culture.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: Yes. And I see the pups that [00:10:00] come out of using this protocol and program that you’ve created are more optimistic. They are more confident.

Less demanding. They know how to ask politely for what they want as opposed to charging through or demand barking, et cetera.

And when someone comes home with a puppy who their breeder, has really followed this program. The house training already have gotten a head start, the crate comfort, already gotten a head start, the exposure to different textures, smells, et cetera, before they’ve left that home environment and before fear periods are closing in.

It’s just remarkable the difference that this program can make.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: I know that you are very passionate about reinforcement training. About, positive techniques, [00:11:00] and I say this in puppy culture, but it’s a point I think that kind of gets lost sometimes, is that a lot of the reason why it’s so profound for breeders to have done this early is that when the puppy gets into the owner’s home and the.

Breeder demonstrates for the puppy owner. Look, this puppy knows how to communicate with you. Look, this works. Look, the puppy’s already primed on that understanding of communication back and forth. In a positive way, it eliminates friction points for the puppy owners and keeps them from reaching for a quick fix in the form of punishment.

So this is where it really dovetails in with the dog trainers, and this is why we have so many dog trainers that are passionate about puppy culture because it, it makes it, it makes their job [00:12:00] easier with the puppy owner.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: It does. Yeah. It does. Yeah. And I don’t get, I don’t get commission or anything for sharing my enthusiasm for your work.

It does make my work easier. Yes. If more breeders are using this and more puppy parents are selecting their dogs having gone through this program before they even come home. So it does make my job easier. And you get to work on the fun stuff, right? I do. You’re not

Jane Messineo Lindquist: dealing with the baseline.

This puppy is screaming at night and I don’t know what to do,

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: yeah, and both of us share the goal, I’m sure of wanting the best relationships possible with new puppies and their parents like that. That is our shared goal, and you’ve just come up and really honed it in on some beautiful techniques I mentioned earlier the term manding.

And you referenced that as well. That’s a new [00:13:00] term for many. Do you mind sharing how you define that?

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Not at all. So Manding is something that I borrowed from, human psychology. And it’s a way of teaching nonverbal humans how to ask for things. So the example that I use that explains how profound it is a case study of a child that was taught to a nonverbal human child that was taught to ask for a train.

And beforehand, this child had all kinds of typical acting out behavior problems that a lot of children like that do have, but as soon as the child had the ability to ask for things and receive them as soon as it could say, I would like that [00:14:00] train self. Injury reduced. Or almost eliminated, I believe, acting out tantrums, all of these things eliminated.

Now. It’s not because the child could get a toy, right? It’s because the child could communicate its need, it’s want of that toy because it was heard and I would not. Equate puppies on an exact level with humans. However, the principle is the same, that if we teach the puppy a behavior, when they have a need, when they want something, they can communicate that to us.

It has profound behavioral benefits outside of the immediate situation. So we use a sit as a man. So the puppy wants something. It needs something. It sits in front of you. It mans. It’s [00:15:00] saying, Hey, I would fill in the blank, whatever it is. Now, here’s the part that’s really cool about this.

Yeah. Is that you don’t even have to gratify the puppies request like the puppy sits in front of you. I’d like you to pay attention to me now. Fluffy, I’m busy. I see you. I love you, but I’m busy. Believe it or not, Fluffy’s okay with that because they can accept that you’ve heard them and decided, no, I can’t right now.

As opposed to the puppy that has no way to communicate what they need, and then they’re just gonna start barking at you and you’re gonna shush the puppy and the puppy’s oh good, I got this. I got

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: something.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Pay attention to me. Yeah. This whole just like ships in the night, you’re totally on two different planes with this. So the manding, again, people tend to confuse it. With sitting politely for padding, which is a different, it’s the Prem Mac [00:16:00] principle. Different thing. It’s what I call behavior homophone, because the puppy is sitting, we think it’s the same thing.

It’s not. Okay. It’s not gatekeeper behavior. It’s not like Before I will pay attention to you, you have to sit. It’s the puppy saying, there’s a possibility if I sit that I’ll get what I want.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: And it’s fascinating to watch how they spontaneously use this skill. I see after teaching it with my own pup that when his fluffy little bottom hits the ground, that’s like his way of saying Please.

Yeah. And just with my kids, if they ask please, it doesn’t mean that they always get everything they’re asking for. And that’s a given. But if I’m taking too long, throwing the ball during fetch. He’s oh, how do I ask for her to give me that? And his little bottom hits the ground, and that’s how he is please throw it.

Aw, [00:17:00] I. That’s so much more enjoyable too and rewarding for the both of us than him jumping on me trying to mouth the ball outta my hands. You’re giving them a tool. On how to politely ask? Yes. Just like with house training, sometimes I’ll have pet parents say, I don’t want my dog scratching at the back door barking.

Both of, I don’t want ’em to damage my door, and it’s annoying when they bark. Great. How can they ask you right to go outside and use. Are we using bells? Like what? What is our, yeah, what’s your plan? Yeah. What’s the polite way? Yeah. And Manding is such a wonderful way to teach a polite way from when they’re tiny, but you can teach it at all ages.

100%.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: That’s a great point. The way I started with Manding actually was with rescue dogs. Because I used to do a lot of fostering. And it was always the first thing I taught [00:18:00] rescue dogs because they come in to your house and maybe they haven’t been abused, usually not truly abused. But certainly the only interaction they’ve ever had with a human has been negative.

In other words, the only time anyone pays attention to this dog is when it’s gonna be something bad. So I started with Manding, with my rescue dogs to teach them, look, we can communicate and guess what? We can intersect. It’s okay. Come seek out my attention. Yeah, I’m actually it’s cool. So yeah,

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: any age And for dogs similar to doodles who when they are demanding, there’s a lot of jumping, knocking over.

It’s a great way for them to say, please. With a little safe personal space without knocking you over

Jane Messineo Lindquist: 100%.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: When someone is looking at a prospective puppy breeder and they’re trying to, [00:19:00] let’s say they’re, Ooh, I love this idea of puppy culture. I wanna find someone’s who’s using that, you’ll see on some breeder sites.

We use ENS. Or early neurological stimulation.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Okay.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: And sometimes that can be said as if it’s the same thing. Can you share what does ENS mean? It’s a buzzword in many circles. And how does that in, is it synonymous with puppy culture? Can you help us discern that a little more? Yeah.

That’s a deceptively

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Yeah. Subject. Interesting though. So early neurological stimulation is something that was popularized by Carmen Vital. He’s a dog breeder, breeds German Shepherds, and it’s a series of manipulations that you do on puppies from six to 16 days old. So you hold them up, you hold them upside down, you put them on their back, you [00:20:00] put them on a cool mat, it’s a couple seconds a piece.

It’s, all together just a few seconds a day and.

Under the correct circumstances, it can have benefits to the endocrine system. It can jumpstart the puppy’s immune system. It can have a lot of positive benefits. But when I was making the film, I was going down to interview Dr. Batt and I started researching ENS because I always do my homework and I was looking at the studies and I was like I actually don’t see any evidence in dogs that this works.

So then I started looking at livestock. And indeed in things like chickens, swine cattle, they’ve used it and it has been shown to have these benefits that purportedly it has for dogs.[00:21:00]

So fast forward now since puppy culture, there have been a couple studies come out and there conflicting. Some have shown that there is a benefit to dogs and some have shown that there’s not, and. The operative difference really is that when you’re coming from a baseline of no handling. So like livestock, like chicks, that nobody’s ever gonna be picking it up every day and doing things.

Yes. Then ENS has a benefit. Again, the places with dogs where they saw ENS have a benefit. Were big commercial kennels where nobody’s touching these puppies ever. So somebody going in and doing some manipulations on these puppies. Yes, there was some benefit. For the average hobby breeder, there’s really, you are already doing ENS.

If you wanna do it, go ahead. If it makes you feel better, but . I don’t do it anymore with my puppies. It’s not conferring a [00:22:00] benefit to your average hobby, home raised litters. Now. You could check off that box and say you do it, but I’m telling you, as a prospective puppy buyer, the least of the protocols in puppy culture is ENS.

Now, this is an area though, that we’ve expanded since then because more research has come out about this different kinds of early neurological manipulations and. One thing that has shown to have a lot of benefits in laboratory animals is licking, okay, so the correlation between maternal styles dams who lick their pups a lot.

Now I’m talking about rat pups. When I say pups. The more high lick dams have puppies with a better regulated HPA [00:23:00] axis. So it’s that stroking and licking and testing fascinating that without getting too into it sort of fine tunes that HPA access so that the puppies have a better, more resilient response to stress.

I do simulated maternal stimulation as opposed to early neurological stimulation. So I do use a soft brush, and brush my puppies because in. The studies they found that they could ameliorate the effects of a low lick mother, a mother that didn’t lick her puppy by simulating it with a soft hairbrush.

So I do a lot of SMS, especially since we have a pretty high C-section rate with our dams, and a lot of times in the beginning they can be slow to come around. So just a tip of your breeder out there, if you ever have a C-section dam, ditch the ENS. Those [00:24:00] puppies don’t need ENS. They’re stressed enough, but the dam likely is gonna be slower to come around if for no other reason than they’re out of it for a few hours after.

The C-section simulated maternal stimulation. I do have an article on this Madcap University. It says Rethinking ENS is the title of the article. So if anybody’s interested in learning more or looking at the licked rat studies, it’s all in there.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: Perfect. I’ll add that in the show notes for people to look it up.

Jane Messineo Lindquist: Perfect. But again, circling back to the puppy buyer, if you are looking for. A good breeder, A breeder that you feel is doing a good job with those puppies that’s gonna have given those puppies a good head start. First of all, let me just start with, puppy culture is not the only early puppy development program out there, [00:25:00] okay?

So just saying puppy culture. Even just doing puppy culture, there are other good breeders. What you really wanna look for are the meaty kind of protocols. So is the breeder. Teaching Maning is the breeder doing leash, walking with the puppies? Is the breeder doing recalls with the puppies?

Do you see , the puppies being crate trained? Do you see the puppies being taken out in a stroller and socialized? These are the kinds of things that you wanna be

looking for.

Corinne Gearhart, The Doodle Pro: That’s really helpful. You mentioned that little stroller piece, right? Still being exposed outside of the home that they’re being bred in.

A common concern I hear from new puppy parents is I can’t take my dog out yet because they haven’t gotten all their vaccinations. And Right. That would be dangerous. So you keep [00:26:00] talking about the socialization window, this opportune time that ends right at the same time that all the vaccinations would be finished. So what would you say to someone who’s feeling anxious about early socialization before their pup is fully vaccinated?

That’s the end of part one of my conversation with Jane Mess Linquist. Next week in part two, we’ll talk about how to socialize your puppy before all their vaccinations are complete. What to avoid and Jane’s must do advice for both breeds and puppy parents. Make sure you are subscribed now so you don’t miss the rest of this great conversation.

Thanks for joining me for this episode of the Doodle Pro Podcast. If you enjoyed the show, don’t forget to rate and review us wherever you get your podcast. [00:27:00] And I invite you to follow me on Instagram at the Doodle Pro for behind the scenes peaks at all of the adorable doodles I work with daily.

What's Your Doodle's Job Title? 🐾

Six quick questions reveal what your Doodle is really up to all day, plus how to help them love their job! 💼🐶

Subscribe to The Doodle Pro Podcast Now: 

Apple PodcastsSpotify

have a pawsome day!

Corinne

The New York Times logo
CBS logo
USA Today logo
NBC News logo
Fox News logo
5280 Top of the Town logo
Corinne Gearhart laughing with a gold microphone against a peach background

oh hey there!

I’m Corinne, The Doodle Pro®

DOODLES ARE DIFFERENT, THEY DESERVE SOMEONE WHO KNOWS WHAT THEY NEED.

That’s why I, The Doodle Pro®, do things differently.

All of my training methods are positive, research-based, and Doodle-specific. 

Search
Untitled (200 × 300 px)

Free Doodle Personality Quiz!

Do you know your doodle as well as you think you do?

Best Brushing Tools for Doodles

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
Your Doodle isn't stubborn. They're unemployed. Find their job title